Telling the truth about history book review

9.83  ·  7,745 ratings  ·  509 reviews
telling the truth about history book review

Telling the Truth About History by Joyce Appleby

Kind of interesting, but when the authors get the point of talking about post-modernism and especially Derrida I had to put aside most of their thoughts and opinions as ill informed and not much more than a popular and superficial reading of his work. The fact that all the information they site on Derrida, Nietzsche (ok, there is one super inflammatory quote they pull from Freddy)and Heideggar come from second hand sources or the opinions of some mysterious persons who have explained this too them makes their critique of the post-modern project kind of weak, and since this was the only part of the book I actually had a good grounding in it makes me wonder about the other parts of the book and the validity of what they are saying. I would expect Historians to goto the original sources of the material they are discussing and not rely solely on others interpretations of the material. But the book does make some interesting observations on the way epistemology has been viewed by history, and even if I dont philosophically agree with the pragmatic turn they make at the end the book did open up some nice avenues of thought. Plus its so damn cute when social scientists and people like historians really try to defend their discipline as being scientifically objective (thats not quite fair, they do move away from this towards their final conclusion, but the structure of residual positivism is still left).
File Name: telling the truth about history book review.zip
Size: 76732 Kb
Published 28.12.2018

Ancient and Medieval History Book Reviews!!! YES OR NO????

Telling the Truth About History book. Read 30 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. Criticizes popular approaches to history, argues th.
Joyce Appleby

Telling the Truth About Aboriginal History

Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Want to Read saving…. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Other editions. Enlarge cover. Error rating book. Refresh and try again.

Site Index

Rarely has the study and teaching of history been the subject of such intense public debate as in the United States today. American historians, however, like the public at large, are a resolutely non-theoretical lot.

On the contrary, as he explains in the introduction to At the Limits of History , in the late s, when he first became acquainted with the postmodern critique of history, he chose merely to distance himself from those historians who ignored or challenged it. The outcome was an at times furious and prolonged debate, in which there were numerous accusations of insane individualism, solipsism, fantasy-mongering, left-wing posturing and hectoring authoritarianism — a debate which no self-respecting historian could easily ignore; though it has to be said that many did. It was no doubt this last qualification that eventually led to his appointment as a lecturer in history at Chichester. In the space of 30 years or so, he believes, these and many other thinkers so deconstructed the foundational and essentialist presumptions of the Western tradition as to leave it entirely bereft of all intrinsic meaning and value. In Rethinking History , a remarkable bestseller, much translated, Jenkins argues compellingly that the conventional view of academic history — that it enjoys the benefits of a uniquely effective epistemology and methodology which enables it to discover from historical facts, properly established, some sort of historical truth, a truth, moreover that can be conveyed to a willing audience by way of historical narrative — is fundamentally flawed. Even the most perfunctory understanding of conventional historical method, properly analysed in a postmodern way, will show that the historian, no matter how well trained he might be, can never really know the past, as the gap between the past and history is an ontological one, one that in the very nature of things cannot be bridged. Nor is it possible for the historian to attain to some kind of methodological objectivity, free from prejudice and bias.

.

.

3 COMMENTS

  1. Hollie H. says:

    New York: W.

  2. Mia F. says:

    Telling the Truth About History (Norton Paperback) [Joyce Appleby, Lynn Hunt, Margaret Jacob] on Author interviews, book reviews, editors' picks, and more.

  3. Todd S. says:

    One of Australia's leading Aboriginal historians takes us to the heart of the 'history war' over our Aboriginal past.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *